pennywise-fucker:

This was a little hard for me, not gonna lie, but I hope you like it still!

Henry:

• Would be completely thrown off
• A very “wtf” look on his face
• He would be inwardly embarrassed, but hide it pretty well
• He’d devour the cake afterwards though
• He’d be kind of a dick afterwards, asking why you’d embarrass him like that
• Really, something like that would just be too much for the guy

Patrick:

• Pretty indifferent
• Not big on that kind of stuff, but doesn’t bother him either
• He’d share the cake with you, but insist you do “something else” for him later
• It’d still be a pretty basic date, mostly him wanting to get through it and wanting you alone

Belch:

• He’d get a little bashful, but happy
• He’d definitely thank you
• He would also share his cake
• He’d gloat about how good of a s/o you are
• Lots of love from him

Vic:

• Sit awkwardly during the singing(as most of us do)
• Definitely would thank you afterwards
• He’d share his cake – you’d probably eat more of it than he would
• He’d attempt to look as content as possible about it
• Grateful but still would find it as awkward as most people do
• Would make sure you knew how sweet you are and how happy he is to be with you